October is typically when Donner Summit and the Mt. Rose Highway experience their first freeze of the season. Black ice and early snow flurries often arrive before drivers have prepared their vehicles for winter. Commuters traveling between Verdi, Truckee, and the Lake Tahoe area may encounter icy curves at highway speed. After a crash, insurance companies frequently blame the weather. California and Nevada law both require drivers to slow down for weather and road conditions, and a driver who fails to do so can be held responsible for the injuries that follow.
At Jensen Oldham Personal Injury Law, our team is led by board-certified personal injury specialist Bob Jensen, who is licensed in Nevada and California, and we handle cases throughout both states. Below, we explain how a Truckee car accident lawyer proves fault after a winter crash, which state’s rules may apply, and what to expect if an insurer blames the weather.
Why a Truckee Car Accident Lawyer Warns About Early Sierra Snow
Winter officially begins in Nevada and the surrounding areas on December 21, but it wouldn’t be surprising to see a winter storm before then. In October 2025, a Pacific storm brought the first heavy snow of the season, with snow reaching Donner Summit as early as October 13. By October 16, drivers had reported multiple spin-outs on I-80 near Truckee, and the California Highway Patrol put chain controls in place over Donner Summit.
Winter storms affect both sides of the state line. During one storm, News 4 reported chain controls on I-80 through the Sierra and on sections of the Mt. Rose Highway, where vehicles over 9 feet tall were also prohibited. These conditions are dangerous for every driver. According to the Federal Highway Administration, crashes on snowy, slushy, or icy pavement kill more than 1,300 people and injure more than 116,800 each year nationwide.
Can Insurers Blame the Weather?
After a winter crash, the at-fault driver’s insurance company may argue the collision was unavoidable. Some insurers describe icy-road crashes as an act of nature, meaning an event caused by natural forces with no human involvement. Storms on I-80 are foreseeable, and Sierra snow has closed the interstate near Donner Summit as late as April 2026. California and Nevada law both expect drivers to plan for these conditions and slow down.
Insurers sometimes raise the sudden emergency doctrine in these cases. Under California’s civil jury instruction on sudden emergency, a driver who claims this defense must prove three things:
- A sudden and unexpected emergency put someone in actual or apparent danger of immediate injury.
- The driver did not cause the emergency.
- The driver acted as a reasonably careful person would have acted in similar circumstances.
California courts deny the benefit of this doctrine when the driver’s own negligence caused or contributed to the dangerous situation. A driver who took an icy curve too fast may have created the emergency they later point to.
Our firm’s very own Cody Oldham was a former insurance defense partner. Thus, he knows how adjusters evaluate claims and the tactics they use to minimize payouts. We use his breadth of experience and expertise to push back when an insurer tries to shift blame onto the weather or onto you.
Which State’s Law Applies to Your Mountain Crash?
Mountain crashes near the state line raise an important question: where did the collision happen? California and Nevada handle shared fault in different ways, and the location of the crash is one of the first details we review in a new claim.
Crashes in Truckee and Donner Summit
California follows a pure comparative fault system, which the California Supreme Court adopted in Li v. Yellow Cab Co. in 1975. Under this rule, liability is divided in direct proportion to each party’s fault, so an injured person’s compensation is reduced by their share of responsibility. If the defense claims you were partly at fault, California’s jury instruction on comparative fault requires the defendant to prove your negligence was a substantial factor in causing your harm.
California generally gives injured people two years to file a personal injury lawsuit under Code of Civil Procedure § 335.1.
Crashes Near Verdi, Reno, and Mt. Rose
In Nevada, under NRS 41.141, you can still recover compensation as long as your share of fault is not greater than the fault of the parties you are seeking recovery from. Your recovery is barred if your negligence is greater than the combined negligence of the defendants.
For most car accidents in Nevada, NRS § 11.190 gives you two years from the date of the crash to file a lawsuit. If your accident involved a government vehicle, the timeline may be even shorter.

How a Truckee Car Accident Lawyer Builds Your Case
A strong winter crash claim connects the other driver’s choices to the harm you suffered. At Jensen Oldham, our team will act quickly to secure evidence and build a clear picture of what happened in the moments before the collision.
Proving Unsafe Speed
California and Nevada both have a basic speed law. In California, drivers must keep their speed reasonable for the weather, visibility, traffic, and road surface. Nevada’s NRS 484B.600 sets the same expectation. These rules apply on top of posted speed limits, so a driver can follow the sign and still break the law on icy roads. We’ll investigate the conditions at the time of your crash to show the other driver failed to slow down.
Reconstructing the Crash
We won’t wait for the insurance company’s report. We’ll work to document the scene, analyze vehicle damage, and preserve evidence like dashcam footage before it is lost or destroyed. Witness statements can help show how fast a driver was traveling and whether they slowed down for the conditions ahead.
Checking Chain Control Compliance
When snow hits, California sets chain requirements based on how bad conditions are. At the most common level on I-80, most vehicles need chains or traction devices, and only four-wheel or all-wheel drive vehicles with snow tires on all four wheels are exempt. On Mt. Rose Highway, vehicles must carry chains or have four-wheel or all-wheel drive with snow-rated tires during chain controls. If the other driver ignored these rules, we can leverage that evidence to show they failed to take reasonable care.
Gathering Reports and Records
We’ll gather police reports from the CHP for California crashes and from the Nevada Highway Patrol for crashes on the Nevada side. We’ll also review medical records, interview witnesses who saw the collision firsthand, and check the road conditions and chain controls in effect at the time of the crash. Caltrans QuickMap provides a real-time view of chain controls, CHP incidents, and highway cameras across California.
Challenging the Sudden Emergency Defense
California courts apply the sudden emergency doctrine only when an unexpected danger appears so suddenly that the driver has no chance to use reasonable judgment. We look closely at what the driver did before the spin-out, including their speed, following distance, and whether chain controls were posted. If those choices helped create the danger, the sudden emergency defense may not hold up.
Finding Every Responsible Party
Some winter crashes involve more than one at-fault party. If a vehicle defect, poor road maintenance, or a commercial employer contributed to the accident, we pursue every responsible party with the goal of maximizing your compensation. When a failed brake, tire, or other component plays a role, drivers who were harmed by a defective product may also have a claim against the manufacturer.
I-80 also carries heavy truck traffic over Donner Summit, and commercial truck crashes require a fast investigation into logbooks and federal compliance data. Trucking companies often have their own lawyers, which is a big reason you need an experienced truck accident lawyer. Bob is a member of the Academy of Trucking Accident Attorneys with experience in these cases, and our truck accident lawyer in Reno team works to hold every responsible party accountable.
Talk to a Lawyer Licensed in Both California and Nevada
A mountain crash can leave you with medical bills, lost income, and an insurance company eager to blame the weather. You shouldn’t have to pay the price for someone else’s careless driving, especially if you are facing serious or catastrophic injuries. As a Truckee car accident lawyer licensed in both states, Bob and our team handle car accident claims for injury victims across Northern Nevada and California, from Sun Valley and Reno to Truckee and Lake Tahoe. If your injuries keep you from traveling, our team can come to your home or hospital room, or we can arrange a virtual consultation.
Bob Jensen brings over 40 years of personal injury experience, and insurance carriers know he is an aggressive litigator who is prepared for court. We work on a contingency fee basis, which means there are no upfront costs and no fee unless we win. Contact our Reno office at (775) 333-7555 or request a free case evaluation today.
Disclaimer: The information provided on this site is for general information purposes only. The information you obtain at this website is not, nor is it intended to be, legal or medical advice. You should consult an attorney or doctor for advice regarding your own individual situation. Use of this website or submission of an online form does not create an attorney-client relationship.

